Are consumers losing faith in product reviews

There are many occasions where we will all rely on reviews to help us distinguish between products or services; especially when they have many different choices.

I recently bought a digital thermometer on Amazon where I had the choice of many hundreds of devices so I relied on the reviews to help me make the decision. Each time I used it, I would get completely random results and it was clear that the device was not as reliable as the reviews had led me to believe. A few days later I received the normal email from Amazon asking me to review it so I posted an accurate and honest negative review. I often review my Amazon purchases as I know that I tend to rely on them myself when buying from the website. Like many customers, I tend to review the items I really like and those that I really don’t.

What happened next was quite an eye opener into the world of Amazon reviews. Over the following few weeks, I received many emails from different addresses, all offering me money to remove the negative review. They even provided a link with instructions on how to do it. Despite me replying stating that I was unwilling to do this, the emails continued. It only stopped once I reported it to Amazon, who, to their credit, took it quite seriously.

This got me thinking. If this has happened to me, how many other people are tempted by the offer of money and go ahead and remove a negative review? How about the positive reviews; do Amazon sellers pay people to post them? Can we even really trust reviews at all?

Countless studies have shown that user-generated reviews can have a big impact on your conversion rates, although, admittedly, many of these studies have been published by companies that sell review management services. It completely stands to reason that user-generated reviews can be very powerful tools in influencing a buying decision; especially with something technical or expensive such as a new TV or a holiday. I would expect that almost everyone reading this post has viewed Amazon, Yelp or TripAdvisor reviews at some point and these have influenced their buying choices. With many marketplaces that are flooded with different product options, many at a similar price, reviews can be a key differentiator. But is the race to win on reviews damaging the trust customers have in them and will this, ultimately, dilute their importance and the impact they have on conversion rates?

Bulk-buying reviews

A recent investigation and report by Which? detailed how easy it is for Amazon sellers to buy verified reviews in bulk. Just a simple Google Search finds a number of companies offering a review generation service. They use techniques to get around the Amazon guidelines and to ensure that the reviews appear to be genuine. Most of the time the process involves providing your product to reviewers for free or at a discounted rate but, for an additional fee, some services will guarantee that your product is returned once the review is submitted. As well as product reviews on marketplaces such as Amazon or Walmart, sellers can also purchase seller feedback and even votes to push positive reviews up. The prices for these services start from around $10 per review but can be much higher for certain categories of products which highlights how valuable genuine-looking reviews can be.

During their study, the Which? researchers posed as an Amazon seller to speak to AMZTigers, a company based in Germany, which claims to have over 60,000 reviewers worldwide to gain an understanding of what their service offers. As well as offering to generate product reviews, the AMZTigers account manager claimed that they can even help a seller gain ‘Amazon Choice’ status within 2 weeks. This is a big consideration as the Amazon Choice label is another big differentiator and it can possibly give the impression that the product is endorsed by Amazon. While Amazon won’t say exactly how an item is awarded ‘Amazon Choice’ status, it has said that the item has to be highly rated, well-priced and available to ship immediately.

The fact that sellers are willing to pay large sums of money and give away free products in exchange for positive reviews is a good indication of how powerful positive reviews are. If not, companies like AMZTigers would not exist.

Amazon’s review policies

Amazon has strict policies aimed at protecting the integrity of reviews. They claim to analyse over 10m reviews every week and to regularly ban, suspend or even take legal action against those that violate those policies. In my own case, as soon as I reported the seller to Amazon, the emails offering to pay me to remove the negative review immediately stopped so I am assuming that Amazon did something about it – although the product is still for sale on Amazon from the same seller.

But is Amazon doing enough? Are they protecting the buyers they rely upon? Companies offering these services can be easily found on search engines so it is hardly a clandestine underground service. I suspect many of us have previously read reviews for an Amazon product that are clearly for a different product or just don’t appear real to know that Amazon’s policies are not preventing this issue from happening. While the problem is not entirely limited to Amazon, it is one of the biggest marketplaces in the world so deserves a lot of scrutiny.

The future of reviews

So will mistrust in reviews start to erode their value and will customers stop using them as part of their purchase decisions? Without action, I think the answer is: Yes. While this is unlikely to be a sudden change, the slow erosion in trust will continue to lessen the impact that reviews have on conversion rates and their value. Trust is such an important aspect in customer experience. It takes a long time to gain and a short time to lose. Perversely, as the value of gaming the system reduces, sellers will be less likely to pay money to obtain fake positive reviews and therefore they may become more trustworthy again but this would be hard to predict.

Ultimately, the solution is for the marketplace platforms to do much more to prevent this happening. I do not believe that my experience was unique and the fact that companies like AMZTigers, Fakespot and ReviewMeta even exist and openly advertise their services tells us that a problem exists. As trust in marketplace reviews diminishes, this will have a knock-on impact on consumer trust in the marketplace itself. If I can’t trust reviews on Amazon, I am less likely to buy from them so resolving this issue is not just the right thing to do, but it could have a long-term commercial impact.

Marketplaces should dedicate more resources to preventing the gaming of their review programmes as well as making the consequences for breaching the terms more severe. In my case, the seller clearly and brazenly breached the terms but is still selling the same product on the platform. Only where the cost and consequences of gaming the system outweigh the benefits will sellers stop.