Study: Corporations on the Track of Start-ups 2021

Study: Corporations on the Track of Start-ups 2021

From playing fields to digital business units and innovation platforms

News

The digital innovation scene is as lively as ever

Even the Corona Pandemic has not changed that. However, the big revolution has failed to appear. While five years ago, Digital Innovation Units were seen as comprehensive solutions for everything, today, their scope is defined clearer and more precisely. Only a few units added noticeable value in earnings to their parent company. This is the result of the study “Corporations on the Track of Start-ups 2021” by Infront Consulting, a subsidiary of KPS AG, and the economy magazine “Capital”. The study is the largest of its kind in the German-speaking area. It shows how well-established corporations and medium-sized enterprises can foster and manage innovation using dedicated innovation units.

The title “Best Digital Innovation Unit 2021” was awarded to “Körber-Geschäftsfeld Digital”, “Wayra” (Telefónica Innovation), and “EnBW Innovation”.

For the fifth time, experts from Infront Consulting and Capital have examined the results of Digital Innovation Units by German corporations and medium-sized enterprises. Both, successfully commercialized innovations close to the core business, as well as outside the core business were evaluated equally:

  • Core business innovation at the borders of today’s business activities, to expand business in existing markets
  • Non-core business innovation, outside of today’s business activities, to tap new markets

The analysis was conducted using an extensive online questionnaire, as well as personal interviews with the Head of the respective Digital Innovation Units. Furthermore, the managers responsible in their parent companies (E.g., CEO, CDO, Strategy Manager) were also questioned. Additionally, a ‘post mortem analysis’ was conducted this year, where closed or re-integrated units were examined.

Main Findings

The study results show the many advances made during the last years, as well as the hurdles needing to be avoided. While the best units are already generating 8-figure revenues each year, other units never exceed the prototyping phase. The key findings of this study include:

The “keyboard of innovation vehicles” further developed – and the best Digital Innovation Units know precisely how to play on it. Self-development, venture clienting, and start-up minority shareholding are currently the most-used innovation vehicles. Traditional start-up accelerator programs have lost parts of their relevance. However, company building and Buy & Build gain in importance.

A clear trend towards KPI-driven management: While Digital Innovation Units were mainly launched without clearly measurable goals, KPIs are widely used for performance measurement today. The expectations are exceptionally high for larger units, which are expected contribute towards the parent company’s financial performance.

Digital Innovation Units have become less funky and have shifted closer towards the core business.  This includes both topic selection and closer cooperation with business units, support functions, and an increased alignment with the company’s strategy.

The Corona Pandemic has not impacted the popularity of Digital Innovation Units. A large wave of shutdowns has not occurred. In fact, the opposite could be observed: Digitalization and innovation have gained even more importance and were prioritized further.

Observing closed units has made clear: Closing does not equal failing! Reasons for shutdowns are diverse and often intertwined with strategy- and management changes in the corporation, missing or incorrect goal setting, structural hurdles, as well as lacking success in scaling the Digital Innovation Units.

The success of a Digital Innovation Unit also comes and goes with its strategy alignment and form of organization. Dr. Felix Lau, Lea-Theresa Münch, and Thomas Sindemann, the study’s directors, have identified two success patterns, differing regarding business purpose and organizational implementation:

  • Digital Business Units focusing on the purpose of scaling, advancing the core business in the area of digitalization, running in parallel to existing business units
  • Innovation platforms with a broader innovation and transformation purpose, bundled in a hub, as an accelerator for innovations within and outside the core business. 

 

The authors’ suggestion derived from this study is: “The blueprints are available. Now, all it takes is courage and strategy, but also endurance, to emerge as a winner in the increasingly fast world of digitalization.”

Digital Lab Award 2021: Germany’s best Digital Innovation Units

Using a two-stage evaluation procedure, the study found the best Digital Innovation Labs in the German-speaking area. These were honored with the Digital Lab Award 2021 in mid-June 2021 by Infront Consulting and Capital. This year’s winners:

Core business innovation

Service

  1. Wayra, Telefónica Innovation
  2. ERGO Innovation & Digital Transformation
  3. SAP.iO und VINCI Energies Digital

Industry

  1. Körber-Geschäftsfeld Digital
  2. Heidelberg Digital Unit
  3. Henkel dx Ventures

Non-core business innovation

Service

  1. EnBW Innovation
  2. Lufthansa Innovation Hub
  3. Greenhouse Innovation Lab für Gruner + Jahr und die Mediengruppe RTL

Industry

  1. Körber Geschäftsfeld Digital
  2. Henkel dx Ventures
  3. Prismade – FutureLab of edding

Background information

“Corporations on the Track of Start-ups 2021” was conducted by the strategy- and management consultancy Infront Consulting & Management, in cooperation with the economy magazine Capital in the first half of 2021. 49 units participated in the study. It was published for the fifth year in a row in 2021.

  • Find the complete study here.

Privacy settings

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others help us to improve this website and your experience. With your consent, we use cookies to analyse the usage of our website.

We also use cookies for marketing to help us measure the success of our marketing efforts. In the settings you will find detailed information about the individual cookies, and you can refuse the use of cookies.

You can change or revoke your selection at any time on any KPS.com page in the footer under Privacy Settings.

Essential Cookies

Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper functioning of the website.

  • Cookie Banner
    Cookie Name: kps-privacy-settings
    Value: PrivacyLevel_0#a
    Storage duration: 4 weeks
    Description: Cookie is required to save cookie settings. This is a purely technical cookie.

HubSpot:

  • Cookie Name: __hs_opt_out
    Storage duration: 6 months
    Description: Cookie is used by the opt-in privacy policy to ask the visitor to accept cookies again. This cookie is set when you give visitors the choice to disable cookies. It contains the string "Yes" or "No".
  • Cookie Name: __hs_do_not_tracking
    Storage duration: 6 months
    Description:: This cookie can be set so that the tracking code does not send any information to HubSpot. It contains the character string "Yes".
  • Cookie Name: __hs_initial_opt_in
    Storage duration: 7 days
    Description: This cookie is used to prevent banners from being displayed every time visitors visit your website in strict mode. It contains the string "Yes" or "No".
  • Cookie Name: __hs_cookie_cat_pref
    Storage duration: 6 months
    Description: This cookie is used to record the categories a visitor consented to. It contains data on the consented categories.
  • Cookie Name: __hs_gpc_banner_dismiss
    Storage duration: 180 days
    Description: This cookie is used when the Global Privacy Control banner is dismissed. It contains the string "yes" or "no"
  • Cookie Name: __hs_notify_banner_dismiss
    Storage duration: 180 days
    Description: This cookie is used when the website uses a Notify consent banner type. It contains a boolean value of True.
  • Cookie Name: hs_ab_test
    Speicherdauer: End of session
    Description: This cookie is used to consistently serve visitors the same version of an A/B test page they’ve seen before. It contains the id of the A/B test page and the id of the variation that was chosen for the visitor.
  • Cookie Name: <id>_key
    Storage duration: 14 days
    Description: When visiting a password-protected page, this cookie is set so future visits to the page from the same browser do not require login again. The cookie name is unique for each password-protected page. It contains an encrypted version of the password so future visits to the page will not require the password again.
  • Cookie Name: hs-messages-is-open
    Storage duration: 30 minutes
    Description: This cookie is used to determine and save whether the chat widget is open for future visits. It is set in your visitor's browser when they start a new chat, and resets to re-close the widget after 30 minutes of inactivity. If your visitor manually closes the chat widget, it will prevent the widget from re-opening on subsequent page loads in that browser session for 30 minutes. It contains a boolean value of True if present.
  • Cookie Name: hs-messages-hide-welcome-message
    Storage duration: 1 day
    Description: This cookie is used to prevent the chat widget welcome message from appearing again for one day after it is dismissed. It contains a boolean value of True or False.
  • Cookie Name: __hsmem
    Storage duration: 7 days
    Description: This cookie is set when visitors log in to a HubSpot-hosted site. It contains encrypted data that identifies the membership user when they are currently logged in.
  • Cookie Name: hs-membershem-csrf
    Storage duration: End of session
    Description: This cookie is used to ensure that content membership logins cannot be forged. It contains a random string of letters and numbers used to verify that a membership login is authentic.
  • Cookie Name: __cfruid
    Storage duration: End of session
    Description: This cookie is set by HubSpot's CDN provider based on their rate limit policies. It expires at the end of the session. Learn more about Cloudflare cookies.
  • Cookie Name: ___cfuvid
    Storage duration: End of session
    Description: This cookie is set by HubSpot's CDN provider based on their rate limit policies. It expires at the end of the session. Learn more about Cloudflare cookies.
Functional cookies

Functional cookies are used by third parties or publishers to display personalised advertisements. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.

External media

Content from video platforms and social media platforms is blocked by default. If cookies from external media are accepted, access to this content no longer requires manual consent.

Changing privacy settings

Imprint

Data protection statement